2003 - THE YEAR AHEAD
The early years of the new century have been brutal for
most investors, as the stock market suffered its worst three-year
decline since the early 1930s. But what does the future hold?
Has the long bear market ended or are we in for a fourth down
year in a row? This is a time of major trend changes in our
opinion, the primary being a shift from the long-term trend
of disinflation to what we believe will be the beginning of
a new reflationary period. The implications for our economy
and financial markets are substantial.
We are optimistic about the future. Yet over the short term,
we find ourselves in a period of above average risk. The U.S.
economy is still struggling to gain momentum, and threats
of war and terrorism loom. Our vision of the financial future
becomes clearer as we look further out in time. Current stock
market valuations are generally reasonable. And we know that,
over time, stock prices grow in line with corporate earnings
which, in turn, grow with GDP. We are confident that the majority
of value-oriented investors will earn favorable returns over
the next three to four years.
As the time horizon shortens, however,
there is more uncertainty. Still, we are expecting positive
stock market returns during the coming year. The probabilities
favor a continuing trend of economic improvement. And, with
very large cash reserves on the sidelines earning meager returns,
there is enormous potential buying power for stocks should
investors begin to regain confidence. Investment success depends
more on one's ability to interpret and adjust to trends and
events as new information becomes available. With that in
mind, what follows is our outlook for the year ahead.
The Economy and Corporate Profits
The U.S. economy is in the grip of an intense tug of war.
On one side are the deflationary pressures borne by the export-based
economies of emerging Asia and the aftermath of the bursting
of the great technology bubble. On the other is the countervailing
reflationary effort of the Federal Reserve Board. The outcome
is important because a sustained period of price deflation
would have onerous implications for both the economy and the
stock market. And history shows that once deflation actually
takes hold, it is very difficult to reverse. However, in recent
months, the deflationary risks have gained wider recognition,
resulting in increased reflationary efforts. In early November
the Fed took a stand, essentially indicating that they will
do whatever is necessary to ensure that deflation does not
take hold. With the European central banks now following suit,
and with the likelihood of additional fiscal stimulus generated
by the growing war on terrorism and the new Republican majority
in Congress, deflation seems far less probable. There may
even be some risk that the reflationary effort will go too
far, resulting in an inflationary surprise down the road,
but the Fed knows how to respond to inflation should that
become an issue.
The risk of a double-dip recession is diminishing
in our opinion, and our outlook is for modest economic growth
this year, say 3%. Continued consumer spending and reasonable
energy costs are the keys to economic health, at least for
now. It was consumer spending that kept the last recession
from becoming very deep, and now the consumer must hold in
there long enough for corporate investment to rebound. A number
of pundits have forecast the imminent demise of the consumer,
but we don't agree. Housing is the consumer's primary asset,
and housing prices are steady. Employment is holding up relatively
well. And while the level of consumer debt is historically
very high, a large portion of that debt is in well-collateralized
mortgages. Furthermore, with interest rates so low, consumer
debt-service requirements are not really that far out of line.
While consumer spending was weaker than expected this holiday
season, we think it will remain strong enough to keep the
economy from slipping back.
On the corporate side, pricing remains very
weak. The inventory overhang is dissipating, but final demand
has only just begun to pick up. The current trend of corporate
downsizing combined with increasing implementation of new
technologies has led to very strong productivity numbers,
but cost cutting can go only so far. We are in need of a new
corporate investment cycle, although that is likely to require
some additional time and an increase in business confidence.
Corporate profits remained depressed in 2002, even as the
economy rebounded. While this may seem an unusual occurrence,
one need only look back to the early 1990s to find a prior
example. The 1991 recession was relatively mild, yet the decline
in corporate profits was severe. The economy recovered in
1992, but it was 1993 before corporate profits rebounded,
then rising a hearty18%. The 2001 recession was similarly
mild, but capital spending fell off a cliff and the corporate
sector was hard hit. While investment spending has now begun
to improve, the weak pricing environment is creating a stiff
profits headwind. Nonetheless, corporate profits should work
higher this year, buoyed by solid productivity growth, improving
sales volumes, and continuing tight cost controls. The bottom
line is that we expect reasonable profits growth in 2003,
particularly as compared to the very poor results of the prior
two years.
The risks in this environment are obvious
- a longer than expected Middle Eastern war could lead to
a sustained period of very high energy prices. That would
weigh heavily on the still nascent economic recovery, spook
the consumer, and perhaps even bring on a second leg of recession.
Terrorism continues to be an important risk as well, particularly
to the short term. The probability of future terrorist acts
is very high, but the likelihood of terrorist acts that result
in a significant, lasting economic consequence is far lower.
Interest Rates and The Bond Market
Interest rates have trended lower for most of the last twenty
years. Over that time, investors have been provided with wonderful
fixed-income returns. But we believe that a major turning
point has been reached. As a result, bond market investors
are at risk, particularly those holding longer-maturity positions
in the highest quality issues. At current levels, the threat
of deflation and fears of further stock market weakness have
been fully factored into bond prices. The Federal Reserve
Board has adopted a strong reflationary stance and central
bankers around the world have begun to follow suit. On the
fiscal side, the patterns of deficit spending have resumed
at both the federal and state levels, and further stimulus
seems likely. Barring the ravages of a true deflationary-debt
spiral or a severe double-dip recession, interest rates on
quality bonds have fallen to the lowest levels likely to be
seen for many years to come.
We believe the Federal Reserve Board will maintain a neutral
posture until it gains some comfort that the deflationary
risk has passed. Therefore, short-term interest rates are
likely to stay very low, for a while longer. But once investors
become convinced that the economic rebound has taken hold,
longer-term interest rates will begin to rise, particularly
in the overvalued U.S. Treasury bond sector. We think interest
rates on the ten-year U.S. Treasury note, currently close
to 4%, will rise to the 5.0% to 5.5% level over the next 12
to 18 months.
So what's a bond investor to do? That's
a difficult question. Interest rates are so low currently,
there is little cushion against capital erosion from falling
bond prices. Maintaining a short-term maturity schedule is
one way to stay out of trouble, but at current levels quality
short-term paper provides little in the way of real returns
(adjusted for inflation). Corporate bonds are attractive relative
to treasury bonds, in our opinion, particularly in the higher-yield
sector. Interest-rate spreads seem far too wide currently,
considering the improving economic outlook and declining default
risk. Nonetheless, investors should recognize the need for
a diversified approach to lower quality debt issues, as they
are quite equity-like in their risk profile.
Municipal bond spreads seem historically
high as well, but we worry about the poor current condition
of state and municipal finances. As such, we are not inclined
to own tax-exempt bond positions in anything but the highest
quality issues. We further note our experience that municipal
bonds are much easier for investors to buy at reasonable prices
then they are to sell, if and when such sales become necessary.
Our belief is that the search for attractive
income will lead increasing numbers of investors away from
bonds and toward dividend-paying stocks. For select companies,
dividend yields are comparable to bond yields and the risks
may be equivalent or less, given our bond market outlook.
Furthermore, dividend payments generally grow over time. There
could be an additional bonus as well, if the Republican Party
follows through on its promises to provide investors with
some relief from the double taxation of dividends.
The Stock Market
The terrible bear market of the last three years is likely
over, in our opinion. But so too is the twenty-year bull market
that began in the early 1980s. We expect the market will experience
a series of cyclical bull and bear moves over the next few
years, the net result of which may be only a moderate gain
in the overall stock market indices. As mentioned earlier,
we anticipate a healthy increase in corporate earnings from
these depressed levels, but we also believe that the overall
level of valuations is likely to work lower. With low interest
rates and little inflationary pressure, current stock market
valuations seem reasonable. But we think that the bursting
of the speculative bubble, combined with last year's bombshell
exposures of corporate malfeasance, could lead to a period
of investor disenchantment with stocks.
We view the current stock market outlook
as being much like that which marked the middle 1970s, following
the devastating 1973/74 bear market. We note that the cyclical
bull market phases of that time period yielded meaningful
investor returns, but it was not like the simple buy-and-hold
environment of the 1990s. The outline for success during those
years was to utilize the periodic strength and weakness to
adjust asset allocation and sector weightings. Many successfully
did so. We see that past as prologue.
Conclusion
The bear market has ended in our opinion, and while another
test of the lows is certainly possible, it seems likely that
we have entered a new cyclical bull market phase for stocks.
As such, increased equity exposure is warranted. Nonetheless,
the economy continues to muddle and corporations are seeing
little in the way of top line growth. Given the risks of this
environment, we are choosing a more cautious stance than might
otherwise seem appropriate. In other words, we are bullish
on the coming year, but also mindful of what could go wrong.
Our strategy is to remain somewhat defensive, utilizing periods
of stock market weakness or testing to add to equity holdings,
and periods of strength to pare our more expensive positions.
As for the bond market, we are very cautious - particularly
in the overvalued, highest-quality government sector. An improving
economy will inevitably lead to higher interest rates.
Looking longer term, our outlook is buoyed
by the enormous technological advances of recent years. We
are in the midst of an amazing technological revolution, and
the pace of advances in the information technologies, genetics,
biotechnology, and even space exploration shows no sign of
slowing. Thus far, the advances are not paying off for the
companies that produce or enable those technologies, but the
productivity enhancements for the users of technology seem
a huge economic positive, longer-term. As students of history,
we are reminded of the far reaching economic benefits that
accompanied the advent of railroads, the automobile, and electricity.
Our future is bright and enormously exciting.
We wish you and yours a healthy, happy, and prosperous new
year.